College Journey
The College Readiness Roadmap: A Family Guide to Success Without Stress
How to find the right schools, stay ahead of the process, and set your child up for success — all while building resilience and a stronger relationship. (Yes, it's possible!)
Created by Josh Roman, CEO of College Journey
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
1
Copyright College Journey 2025
You're Not Alone, and You Don't Need to Be Perfect
Welcome Parents (and students!)
Whether you're right in the middle of applications, have a child just starting high school, or are somewhere in between, we're glad you're here and you're in the right place.
""With all this information, why is the college process still so stressful and confusing?" — High school parent
As a parent of a high schooler and an insider in the world of Ivy League admissions, I asked myself this question constantly. I saw friends, neighbors, and colleagues—all brilliant, capable people—completely overwhelmed by the college journey.
They were drowning in rankings, stressed by deadlines, and paralyzed by the fear of making a costly mistake. They were having the same tense dinner-table conversations we were.
"Why is the whole trajectory of my life based on decisions I make before my frontal lobe even develops?" — High school student
I saw high school students obsessing over "Top 20" schools and having the perfect college resume, rather than discovering what they really enjoyed and finding schools that were a great fit. And some - including me - arrived at school unprepared and out of place, setting themselves up for failure.
And with AI reshaping the job market, the question 'Is college worth it?' is more important than ever. We believe the answer is yes—if it's the right college. A 'right-fit' education is no longer just about a diploma; it's the best way to develop the uniquely human skills that will always be in demand.
How to This Guide is Organized
- Process Roadmap (Pages 5-10) with grade-specific activities & outcomes
- Thematic Deep-Dives (pages 11-18) on Relationships, College List-building, Finances, Essays, & more
- Common Mistakes & Quick-reference Tools (pages 19-21)
"All too often, I see a tsunami of anxiety crashing into high schools and overwhelming countless kids. Instead of focusing on who they are, what they want from life, and how college should fit their goals, kids are running themselves ragged trying to turn themselves into someone they think colleges want (spoiler alert: that is the opposite of what they want)." — Hey AdmissionsMom: Real Talk from Reddit
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
2
Copyright College Journey 2025
Going In With Your Eyes Wide Open
The "Business" of Admissions
- You should think about colleges as businesses that sell educational "spots" (think airlines trying to fill a seats on a plane) rather than simply places to learn. It's unfortunate, but that's the reality of today's college landscape
- Schools are now using AI and advanced analytics to optimize their profits, so you should as well!
- Many "safety" schools aren't safe anymore (e.g. Auburn: 85%→24% acceptance rate) — this is a big change from 20 years ago
"Targets are now reaches and Safeties are now targets" — High school student
What Actually Matters in Admissions (according to NACAC)
Foundation
- Grades in college prep courses (77%)
- Overall GPA (74%)
- Curriculum rigor (64%)
Differentiators
- Character attributes & Activities (28%)
- Essays (19%)
- Demonstrated interest (16%)
Variable Impact
- Test scores are down in importance (but rebounding)
Key Takeaway
- This 2023 survey of admissions officers shows a move toward holistic review emphasizing grades, character, and essays over test scores… but test scores are still important, and the process is increasingly competitive
- Character, self-awareness, and passion matters! Trying to "game the system" to get into a specific school doesn't work — focus on authenticity and fit over rankings.
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
3
Copyright College Journey 2025
Overall Timeline
"Prep for college apps really does start in the womb" — High school student
1
9th Grade
🎓 Build Academic Foundation
📊 Introduce PSAT Practice
💰 Open 529 Plan (if not already saving!)
🧠 Establish Study Habits
2
10th Grade
🎓 Increase Course Challenge
📊 PSAT Preparation
💰 Net Price Calculators
🧠 Explore Activities & Build Self-Awareness
3
11th Grade
🎓 Maximum Rigor
📊 SAT/ACT First Attempt
💰 Financial Workshops for Parents
🧠 Weekly Stress Checks
⚠️ Identify Teacher Recommendations
4
12th Grade
🎓 Maintain Performance
📊 Final Testing (Fall)
⚠️ Application Deadlines
💰 FAFSA & CSS Profile
🧠 Decision Support
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
4
Copyright College Journey 2025
9th Grade
Core Theme: "Building Without Pressure"
"High school needs to be about high school, not four years of college prep. As adults, we remember that it's an incredibly special time in life, and we don't want to ruin that time with a constant focus on college." — Grown and Flown: How to Support Your Teen, Stay Close as a Family, and Raise Independent Adults
Responsibility Matrix
Top-3 Outcomes for 9th Grade
- Academic Foundation: Strong GPA with rigorous coursework
- Activity Exploration: Find genuine interests, not resume fillers
- Financial Awareness: Open 529 if needed, start a conversation about the family budget
Things to watch:
- Grade trends below 3.0 GPA
- Social media inappropriate content
- Warning signs of over-scheduling
Stress-Less Protocol
Establish a "College-Talk" Zone: Establish one day a week (often Sunday afternoon) when you talk about college. Keep things light and aspirational, but it sets the tone that high school isn't only about college prep and creates a cadence that will be helpful in the coming years. And if your child isn't ready to talk about college? That's OK too. Fostering curiosity, exploration, and a love of learning are the foundation of success in high school, college, and beyond.
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
5
Copyright College Journey 2025
10th Grade
Core Theme: "Exploration & Challenge"
"If you couldn't write about this on your college application, would you still do it? If the answer is no, then you shouldn't be doing it." — MIT Dean of Admissions
Responsibility Matrix
Top-3 Outcomes This Year
- Academic Intensification: Keep a "growth mindset" and look for challenging courses
- College Categories: Start to discuss various types of colleges, majors, and careers
- Financial Reality: Know family's realistic price range
Path Check-In
Family Discussion: "Is 4-year college the only path?"
- Alternative options: Community college, gap year, trade school, military
- Set aside any value judgements and have an open conversation about various life paths
"How many of y'all's dream college in 9th grade was the same as your dream college during application season?" — High school student on r/ApplyingToCollege
"Do what you love and pursue it hard, because it will make your life more fulfilling and interesting, regardless of whether or not you get into XXXXX College. And, it has the nice side effect of being what colleges like to see." — Hey AdmissionsMom: Real Talk from Reddit
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
6
Copyright College Journey 2025
11th Grade
Core Theme: "Junior Year is the New Senior Year"
"I am a junior who is freaking out about college apps. Please talk to me, I need advice."
— High school student
Responsibility Matrix
"Encourage students to drive the college search but allow for detours. A handful of the teenagers I followed during their senior year ended up at what they told me were their “dream” schools. When I checked in with them their first semester of freshman year, however, they were unhappy. They’d jumped through all the hoops to get in: the demanding classes, the high SAT scores, the legion of extracurricular activities. But for what—to do it all again in college?" — Who Gets In and Why: A Year Inside College Admissions
Top-3 Outcomes This Year
- Testing: At least one SAT or ACT test to determine baseline and path forward
- Initial College List: Move from vague ideas to specific schools and start research
- College Resume: Learn how colleges look at your activities, character, grades, and more to understand who you are
Growth Check-In
Family Discussion: "What do you imagine college will be like? What are you most worried about? What are you most excited about?"
- The goal with these curiosity questions is not a specific answer, but to plant the seeds of self-awareness and get your child thinking about what is actually important to them
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
7
Copyright College Journey 2025
11th Grade - Timeline
Fall Semester
- Take PSAT (October) for National Merit
- Maintain grades while increasing activities
- Begin preliminary college list (15-20 schools)
- Research testing options and prep resources
- Attend "Paying for College" workshops
Spring Semester
- CRITICAL: Ask 2-3 teachers for recommendation letters BEFORE summer
- Take SAT/ACT first time (March/April)
- Plan summer visits (3-5 schools max)
- Weekly stress level check-ins
Summer
- Write first draft Common App essay and any college-specific supplementals
- Complete demographic sections of applications
- Identify "sanity preserver" friend for support
- Evaluate college visits with criteria
Mental Health Notes
- The process "gets real" for juniors and this can create significant additional levels of stress and anxiety
- Teens often display anxiety differently than adults, so watch for withdrawal, anger, or significant changes in behavior
- They're talking with fellow students, teachers, and other adults about college, so you can model healthy stress management with curiosity and interest in what they're experiencing, rather than comparing them, shaming them, or judging them. It's OK that they don't have all the answers or know how to describe their experiences.
- Seek professional counseling if anxiety exceeds normal levels (for your student or YOU!)
"The most important thing a parent can do for their high school junior is continue to offer support and a listening ear. Even the calmest of teens will hit rough patches, and angry rants or tears of exhaustion will emerge." — Grown and Flown: How to Support Your Teen, Stay Close as a Family, and Raise Independent Adults
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
8
Copyright College Journey 2025
12th Grade - Applications
Responsibility Matrix: Fall Semester (September-November)
Responsibility Matrix: Spring Semester (December-May)
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
9
Copyright College Journey 2025
12th Grade
Steering the Ship Through The Storm
This is the challenging point. You've got this. Use your tools, work your plan, and take breaks now and again for both you and your child.
"One of the challenging things about the long college process is the hamster wheel of your mind spinning through all that needs to be done by your kid and to a lesser extent by you. Make a spreadsheet or paper file or whatever it takes to keep from going over and over the seemingly endless list of tasks and decision points." — Grown and Flown: How to Support Your Teen, Stay Close as a Family, and Raise Independent Adults
Remember to:
- Get your applications ready 1-2 weeks before the deadline
- Print them out via PDF and have someone else review them before submitting
- Prepare for rejection. It is inevitable. Remember that "Where you go is not who you'll be" and "it's not about the destination, it's about the journey." These may seem like cheesy slogans, but they distill ancient wisdom that is even more true today.
"is it just me or does anyone feel empty after submitting apps?" — High school student on r/ApplyingToCollege
Summer Transition - "Adulting Handoff"
- Let your child enjoy successfully completing high school - and recognize that they will start to pull away in preparation for "heading off to college." It's normal and expected!
- Healthcare management transfer (insurance, prescriptions)
- Financial literacy final lessons (banking, budgeting)
- Critical: Obtain legal documents when your child turns 18 (e.g. Healthcare Proxy, Power of Attorney)
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
10
Copyright College Journey 2025
Relationship Preservation Toolkit, pt 1
"Why do parents get more stressed than the one actually going to college" — High school student
Keeping Your Family Intact Through the Chaos
Establish "No College-Talk" Zones and/or once a week "College Check-in" Times
- Designated times/spaces off-limits (dinner, bedrooms, weekends)
- Sunday afternoon check-ins to plan for the week, set goals, etc.
Chart the Madness
- Use a shared family tracking system to externalize mental load
- School-based tools like Naviance & Scoir can help, but simple Google Sheet is often the best
Parent "Sanity Preserver"
- Have a designated friend for venting (not your student!)
- If you're coordinating with a spouse or partner, establish your own roles and boundaries:
- Who is doing what, how you'll resolve differences, and keeping everyone in the loop
- Don't hesitate to find a therapist or guide through the process
Communication Themes by Grade Level
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
11
Copyright College Journey 2025
Relationship Preservation Toolkit, pt 2
"Plead the Fifth" Scripts for Students
Family get-togethers and social interactions can be very stressful for students. They will inevitably be asked questions about college that they do not know the answer to, or do not feel comfortable sharing. Respect where they are in the process and help them build the skills to manage uncertainty and protect their own mental health.
- "My parents and I are still exploring options. We'll share news when we're ready!"
- "I'm focusing on my current classes right now. We'll talk about college later this year."
- "Thanks for asking! I don't know yet. I'm taking it one step at a time."
"You say 'we' and 'our' when talking about your student's school experiences... You are not joining the sorority, or taking Bio 101, or applying to college, so stop that! This subtle pronoun choice communicates a lot to your student. It can make them feel pressured to achieve the things that will make you happy." — Grown and Flown: How to Support Your Teen, Stay Close as a Family, and Raise Independent Adults
Conflict Prevention Strategies
- ✅ Ask "How can I help?" before taking over
- ✅ Celebrate small wins together weekly
- ✅ Student-led parent-teacher conferences
- ✅ Be open with your own fears, hopes, and dreams, and how they may be driving some of your behavior
- ✅ Weekly family stress temperature checks
- Both of you can "check in" by answering the question "How stressed am I on a scale of 1-10?"
- Try not to put a value judgement on a high or low score, but use it as an opportunity to connect and share what's real for you in the moment and at this point in the process
"It can be difficult to manage our own frustrations and anxiety about college and how seriously we think our child is taking the process. Ideally, we can stay open-minded and curious about what they need in the moment and model healthy responses to stress. Worrying about the future is normal, but does not need to become a habit. " — Jud Brewer, MD PhD
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
12
Copyright College Journey 2025
Building Your College List
The "Best Fit" Formula
- The "best" school is the one where your child will thrive, not the one with the best ranking
- 40-40-20: Academic fit (40%) + Personality fit (40%) + Financial fit (20%) = Actual happiness
- Your dream school ≠ Their dream school ≠ Their RIGHT school
Personality Match?
Building your college list is a bit like dating. If your child's personality and the college's personality "click," everything is easier and they'll feel more secure and be more successful. If there's a mismatch, it could work, but it's an uphill battle (and probably some tears…)
Take the free College Journey student personality quiz to learn your child's College Personality and get 3 schools that are a great fit for who they are and what your family is looking for.
Give it a try for free: https://app.collegejourney.ai/quiz/recommendations
Building Your Best-Fit List
Every school on the list should be one your child would feel good about going to. Once they're in, it's curiosity and hard work that make the difference, not the school's ranking.
Don't know where to start? The College Journey Complete Roadmap uses AI to match your child's personality, academic profile, and over 60 other factors to curate a list of 10-15 best-fit schools, along with all of the information you need as a parent to make good decisions and be one step ahead of your child.
Learn more: https://collegejourney.ai/complete-roadmap
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
13
Copyright College Journey 2025
Financial Reality Check
"I was accepted into almost every school i wanted but i have no clue how i'll afford it" — High school student on r/ApplyingToCollege
Front-Loaded Financial Timeline
Freshman
Open 529, understand family budget constraints
Sophomore
Run first Net Price Calculators on different college types
Junior
Create financially viable college list from the start
Senior
Compare aid packages, understand debt implications
Key Financial Tools & Rules
- Net Price Calculator Demo: Visit CollegeJourney.ai for calculator
- Merit Aid vs. Need-Based Aid: Review aid package for each college
- Private schools often offer competitive packages to state schools - don't rule them out!
5 Conversation Starters for Money Talks
These may feel uncomfortable now, but you're teaching your child how to make good financial decisions later.
- "What's a realistic total budget for college, including living expenses?"
- "If we need loans, what amount feels manageable for our family?"
- "Are there schools we should consider for merit aid opportunities?"
- "What expenses can we start planning for now?"
- "How will college costs affect other family financial goals?"
"if you're a senior right now and you're trying to decide between colleges and you finally got your financial aid offer... and you can't really afford it, it's too late. Financial fit has to be part of [your decision-making] early on." — Jeff Selingo, "How to Balance Fit, Cost, and Prestige when Choosing Your School"
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
14
Copyright College Journey 2025
Essays
The Essay Reality Check
- Truth: Essays matter more than ever as test scores become optional and GPAs inflate
- The 650-Word Window: Your ONE chance to be three-dimensional in a data-driven process
- Parent Alert: This is where helicopter parenting (writing!) crashes the plane
The Three Essay Commandments
- Show Your Growth, Not Your Grades - They already have your transcript
- Be Memorable, Not Impressive - AOs read 50+ essays per day
- Write Like You Talk - If it sounds like a thesaurus threw up, start over
"The best essay I ever read was about a student's relationship with their kitchen sponge. I'm not kidding. It revealed responsibility, family dynamics, and personal growth. Your essay doesn't need to be about building houses in Guatemala." — Ivy League admissions officer
Supplemental Essays
- "Why Us" Essays: Research specific professors, programs, traditions
- Short Answers: Different anecdotes than main essay - show range
Red Flags
- Using AI: Your story, your voice
- Plagiarism: Including "inspired by" Reddit/YouTube examples
- Ghost Writing: This is obvious
- Trauma Dumping: Be authentic, but if your therapist would be concerned, reconsider
Parents: Help your child start early, and help them uncover their authentic story. This is an opportunity for colleges to learn about them — but ALSO an opportunity for them to learn about themselves.
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
15
Copyright College Journey 2025
Crisis Protocols
When Plans Don't Go According to Plan
"I feel like such a failure" — High school student
Red Flag Triage Matrix
Crisis Response Protocols
- Academic: Meet with school counselor (sooner rather than later)
- Financial: Contact college financial aid offices for appeal processes
- Emotional: Seek professional counseling, implement regular check-ins
- Timeline: Research rolling admission schools, consider gap year
Emergency Contacts Quick Reference
- Mental Health Crisis: National Suicide Prevention Lifeline: 988
- Financial Aid Help: Federal Student Aid Information Center: 1-800-433-3243
- College Counseling: National Association for College Admission Counseling (NACAC)
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
16
Copyright College Journey 2025
Alternative Pathways
There is an increasing understanding that college is NOT the right choice for every graduating senior. The world has changed a great deal in the past 20 years, and the goal should be finding the right fit for your child at this point in their growth trajectory; not just following the herd into college. In a world increasingly built on technology and artificial intelligence, independence and self-awareness are more important than rule-following.
Gap Year Programs
Taking a year to work, travel, and/or take college classes from home can be exactly what your child needs to prepare for their next step. Colleges do not see this as a negative. Look into structured vs. independent options with specific program examples, or design your own gap year.
Community College Transfer
Starting with 2 years at a community college before transferring can lead to exactly the same degree as a 4 year program (at lower cost!) Just ensure there are formal "articulation" programs so that credits and coursework transfers.
Trade Schools & Military
Trade schools and apprenticeship programs are increasingly valuable options, with high-paying career prospects. And a military enlistment can be a stepping-stone to college and a level of maturity that's just right for your child.
"We treat college-going as if it is a one-size-fits-all moment. Some eighteen-year-olds are not ready academically, socially, or in terms of their ability to live as independent adults... But thriving in college is our goal, not merely attending college. And, succeeding in college for your teen means beginning college when they are ready, not when their classmates are." — Grown and Flown: How to Support Your Teen, Stay Close as a Family, and Raise Independent Adults
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
17
Copyright College Journey 2025
Special Circumstances
First-Generation College Students
- Decode the Jargon: Look up or ask about common terms (EFC, CSS Profile, ED vs EA)
- Fee Waiver Resources: Application and testing fee relief is available!
- Self-Promotion: Don't be afraid to put together a "Brag sheet" for recommendation writers
- Engage Support Organizations: There are many orgs out there to help. This is not a negative on your application.
International Students
- Testing Requirements: TOEFL/IELTS scheduling and prep
- Credential Evaluation: WES, ECE services for transcript translation
- F-1 Visa Timeline: Post-admission process with I-20 and SEVIS fees
Regional System Navigation
- California & New York Residents: The UC/CSU system in CA, and the SUNY/CUNY systems in NY have their own requirements and applications.
- Other State-Specific Programs: Review timelines and requirements for each state
Learning Differences & Disabilities
- Accommodations Timeline: Extended time for testing and other accommodations are available during the application process
- Campus Disability Services: Review services offered at each school and call to speak with on-site advisors about your child's unique needs. Some schools specialize in student support!
- Transition Planning: If your child is on an IEP, speak with your resources to understand how to do a handoff. High school graduation is not the end of services in many cases.
"Going through the college process alone is so stressful" — High school student on r/ApplyingToCollege
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
18
Copyright College Journey 2025
Common Mistakes & Reminders
Do These Things!
- ✅ Student uses own email account for college communications
- ✅ Student checks email account regularly after applications are submitted — colleges often reach out!
- ✅ Parents avoid using "we" language about student's applications
- ✅ Financial aid applications are completed before college admissions deadlines
- ✅ Thank you notes sent to recommendation writers
- ✅ Backup plans in place for each stage of the process
Reminders for Overwhelmed Parents
- ✅ College fit matters more than prestige
- ✅ Private colleges can often be cost-competitive with state schools - don't rule them out right away
- ✅ Mental health is non-negotiable — for you and your child
- ✅ Financial debt impacts future choices
- ✅ Your child's journey is unique
- ✅ This too shall pass - you will survive this process
Additional Help
Get more information, free tools, guides, and personalized assistance at CollegeJourney.ai.
Or email me: josh@collegejourney.ai
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
19
Copyright College Journey 2025
Quick Reference Timeline
1
August 1
Common App opens
2
October 1
FAFSA and CSS Profile open
3
October (last Saturday)
Final SAT/ACT for early applications
4
November 1/15
Early Decision/Action deadlines
5
January 1-15
Regular Decision deadlines
6
May 1
National College Decision Day
Grade-Specific Reminders
- Junior Fall: Take PSAT for National Merit consideration
- Junior Spring: Sign up for SAT or ACT early to get a baseline
- Summer: Start work on essays
- Summer: Start building your college list (visit if possible!)
- Senior Fall: Submit early applications with all components
- Senior Spring: Compare financial aid offers before May 1
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
20
Copyright College Journey 2025
Final Thoughts & Encouragement
This guide is designed to reduce complexity, prevent critical mistakes, and preserve family harmony throughout the college application process. By following the chronological roadmap and implementing the stress reduction protocols, you can navigate this challenging time while maintaining healthy relationships and achieving successful outcomes.
But even if you "do everything right", admissions to any college is still not guaranteed. I've worked with students with perfect GPA and SAT scores who didn't get into their top choice school, and I've seen students with "middle of the pack" scores and activities get into stretch schools.
"The problem is that, in any given year, around 50,000 students are trying to funnel themselves into the same tiny teacup of colleges. And that's just not going to work. There are literally hundreds of amazing schools that are actively seeking all kinds of students — you simply need to find the one (or more!) out of the many that fit you." — Hey AdmissionsMom: Real Talk from Reddit
Your college journey is not just about getting into a school—it's about finding the right fit for your student's unique goals, interests, and needs. Trust the process, stay organized, and keep communication open. With proper planning and perspective, this experience can strengthen your family bonds rather than strain them, and set your child up for success in life, which is the real goal.
"The nature of a student’s college experience—the work that he or she puts into it, the skills that he or she picks up, the self-examination that’s undertaken, the resourcefulness that’s honed—matters more than the name of the institution attended." — Where You Go Is Not Who You'll Be
I find it helpful to remind parents (and students!) that this is often the first time when you're both working together on an adult-level challenge, as adults (or near-adults.) It's as much a time of transition for you as it is for them. Your child is watching you more closely than you think, and how you show up for them now will set patterns and habits that will help define your relationship with them in college and beyond.
If you have the courage to approach this with compassion, curiosity, and a real desire to connect, you and your child will both be successful, no matter what college they go to.
With hope, gratitude, and support,
Get more tools at CollegeJourney.ai
21
Copyright College Journey 2025